Tech lawsuits defined 2026 — and lawmakers want more
Lawmakers pushed to eliminate forced arbitration for online child exploitation while Paris Hilton advocated for the Defiance Act to penalize deepfakes.
By Dillip Chowdary • Nov 18, 2026 • Source: The Verge

At a glance
- Subcommittee Hearing
- November 18, 2026
- Consolidated Lawsuits
- Approximately 180 cases against Roblox
- Legislative Window
- Roughly three weeks remaining in 2026 session
- Synthetic Victims
- Over 50 million individuals affected
- Deepfake Creations
- Over 100,000 explicit files targeting Paris Hilton
- Key Legislation
- Defiance Act and child cyber injury arbitration bills
In this post
Lawmakers on Capitol Hill are moving to dismantle legal shields for online platforms and synthetic media creators as the 2026 legislative calendar winds down, advancing proposals to ban mandatory arbitration and authorize civil lawsuits for nonconsensual intimate deepfakes. As detailed in The Verge's report, members of a Senate Judiciary subcommittee held hearings to bar tech companies from routing child exploitation claims into private arbitration, while bipartisan House members rallied support for legislation granting victims direct access to federal court.
This report details the dual-track push across Capitol Hill to expose gaming platforms to jury trials, end contract clauses applied to minors, and impose civil financial liability on deepfake generators. It is essential reading for corporate counsel, trust and safety professionals, tech policy analysts, and consumer advocates monitoring digital liability, Section 230 revisions, and end-of-year legislative maneuvers in Washington.
01Senate scrutiny over child arbitration clauses
Senate Judiciary subcommittee chairman Josh Hawley and ranking member Dick Durbin introduced legislation to invalidate forced arbitration agreements in cases involving child sexual exploitation and child cyber injuries. The bill targets standard terms of service that block families from filing civil lawsuits, defining eligible harms to include reputational damage, mental suffering, and death. Hawley argued that courtroom juries provide an essential enforcement hammer against tech companies seeking to evade regulatory compliance.
The immediate focus of Tuesday's hearing was Roblox, which faces roughly 180 consolidated lawsuits over allegations that predatory users groomed minors on its gaming platform. Plaintiffs argue the company relies on arbitration clauses accepted by children under 10 years old to suppress public litigation. Hawley asserted that the jury system remains corruption-proof, emphasizing that opening courthouse doors provides victims with meaningful leverage against corporate negligence.
02Legal discovery fights and platform defenses
Under standard arbitration proceedings, legal documents, internal corporate communications, and deposing records remain sealed from the public rather than being entered into court records. Lawmakers highlighted how recent judicial proceedings against Meta unsealed significant internal records regarding youth safety practices that private arbitration would have kept confidential. Opening these disputes to public juries would expose internal safety telemetry, executive correspondence, and moderation logs to public scrutiny.
Note: Roblox maintains that forced arbitration enforcement does not reflect its operational safety record, stating that safety has remained foundational since its launch. The company noted that it enforces mandatory age verification checks for chat, automatically restricts users under 16 to protective default profiles, and blocks images and video transmissions inside player messaging channels.
Roblox global head of public policy Nicky Jackson Colaço stated that arbitration arguments distract from actual platform safety initiatives. However, critics counter that platform controls have failed to prevent bad actors from contacting young players across community experiences. Opening standard civil discovery would force gaming networks to substantiate safety claims by disclosing platform metrics, moderation staff ratios, and incident reports directly to juries.
03Lame-duck calendar and competing legislative proposals
Advertisement
Tech Pulse Daily
Get tomorrow's pulse first
Join engineers who read Tech Pulse before stand-up. Free, weekday mornings.
With just over three weeks remaining before the current congressional session concludes, lawmakers face a compressed legislative window. Republican leadership is prioritizing confirmation votes for President Donald Trump’s judicial and executive nominees, including positions at the Federal Communications Commission, alongside negotiations over the annual National Defense Authorization Act. Incoming power shifts in January add urgency for sponsors seeking to attach child safety measures to must-pass budget packages.
Two competing proposals now seek to curtail corporate arbitration clauses across online platforms, offering distinct scopes of legal coverage for consumers and families seeking judicial remedies.
| Measure | Lead Sponsors | Primary Scope | Covered Harms |
|---|---|---|---|
| Child Cyber Injury Bill | Hawley (R-MO), Durbin (D-IL) | Child exploitation and online grooming | Mental suffering, reputational harm, death |
| Comprehensive Arbitration Ban | Blumenthal (D-CT), Britt (R-AL), Booker (D-NJ) | Platform harms and consumer data | Data privacy violations, child safety |
Northwestern University law professor Myriam Gilles testified that public lawsuits create rapid corporate behavioral changes that administrative regulations frequently fail to produce. Gilles remarked that after testifying numerous times on arbitration, she never anticipated addressing contracts enforced against nine-year-olds. She noted that companies alter internal practices swiftly once forced to defend corporate conduct in front of open juries.
04Civil liability under the Defiance Act
A few blocks from the Senate hearing room, Representatives Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Laurel Lee hosted a joint press conference to advance the Defiance Act. The bipartisan bill creates a direct private right of action for victims of nonconsensual sexually explicit deepfakes, allowing targeted individuals to sue content creators for civil damages. Sponsors designed the financial penalties to alter the economic incentives of generating synthetic pornography.
Litigation has emerged as an effective tool for victims of online harms because broad reform measures like Section 230 overhauls have stalled in Congress. While lawmakers passed narrower items such as the Take It Down Act, civil liability allows individuals and state attorneys general to bypass platform immunities. The Defiance Act establishes monetary exposure that directly penalizes individuals who weaponize artificial intelligence against nonconsenting targets.
05Personal accounts of synthetic media abuse
Advocate Paris Hilton joined lawmakers to demand passage of the Defiance Act, recounting how an unconsented intimate recording distributed when she was 19 disrupted her life. Hilton testified that bad actors have generated more than 100,000 explicit synthetic images and videos depicting her. She stressed that over 50 million individuals have experienced sexual deepfake exploitation, warning that everyday victims lack the resources necessary to defend themselves.
Student advocate Elliston Berry shared that a classmate generated explicit synthetic images of her middle school friend group using an ordinary social media photograph when she was 14 years old. The fabricated material circulated rapidly throughout her school community, destroying her sense of safety within seconds. Berry told lawmakers that legal recourse must keep pace with technological tools so that victims are not left without court access.
Frequently asked questions
What does the Defiance Act propose to do for deepfake victims?
The Defiance Act allows victims of nonconsensual sexually explicit deepfakes to file civil lawsuits against content creators for financial damages. The bill aims to raise the legal and economic costs associated with generating synthetic explicit material.
Why are lawmakers targeting Roblox over forced arbitration?
Lawmakers accuse Roblox of using mandatory arbitration clauses to block court cases alleging that minors, some under 10 years old, were groomed on the platform. The platform currently faces approximately 180 consolidated lawsuits over child protection failures.
How does the Hawley-Durbin arbitration bill differ from the Blumenthal-Britt-Booker proposal?
The Hawley-Durbin bill renders arbitration unenforceable for cases involving alleged child sexual exploitation or child cyber injuries resulting in reputational harm, suffering, or death. The Blumenthal-Britt-Booker bill introduces a distinct framework that explicitly covers data privacy violations alongside platform harms.
What safety measures does Roblox claim are currently active?
Roblox stated that it requires age checks for chat features, restricts users under 16 to age-based accounts with protective defaults, and blocks image and video sharing in chat. The company contends that its legal positions on arbitration do not define its safety record.
Sources
Author
Dillip Chowdary
Writes Tech Bytes coverage of AI, engineering, and the tools that actually ship. Editor of Tech Pulse Daily.
Related on Tech Bytes
Advertisement